The song heard at the end of each episode as
Scott ends the plugs section. Jesse Ventura often gets trapped in the plug bag as it is closing. He can sometimes be heard still trapped in the plug bag on episodes he is not a featured guest, 'coincidentally' when James Adomian is on the show. Many remixes have been added to the end of the song, usually by Tiny or by a character with a similar vocal range to Paul F. Tompkins.
At the beginning of 2016, Scott retired Closing Up the Plug Bag and recorded a new closing theme,
Gonna Listen to Some Plugs, on Episode 393: Peanut Awareness by Ben Schwartz and Horatio Sanz.
The original "Closing Up The Plug Bag Theme" was created on
Episode 163: Burning Love. It is performed by,
The remix of the "Closing Up The Plug Bag Theme" was created on
Episode 181: Happy Endings. It is performed by,
Remix #2 Edit
The theme had a new addition in
Episode 301:They're Twins Jonah! with Tiny adding "That's a good song!" It officially became part of the song a few episodes later.
Remix #3 Edit
The theme was remixed again by
Tiny in Episode 320: Charging Kids. He added a second "That's a good song!" after the original "That's a good song!" that ended remix #2.
Remix #4 Edit
Another addition came to the theme in
Episode 323: Pie Quiz with Tears for Fears when the Pie Minister added the phrase "That is a good song." after the two times Tiny says "That's a good song!"
Remix #5 Edit
The theme was remixed yet again by
Tiny in Episode 326: 2014 Holiday Spectacular. He added a surprising "That song's okay!" after the Pie Minister's "That is a good song" from Remix #4.
Remix #6 Edit
The theme was remixed once again by
Tiny in Episode 343: Athlete's Head, who upped the ante by adding "That's a great song!" as the remix's latest final line.
Remix #7 Edit
The theme was remixed a seventh time by
JW Stillwater in Episode 348: Is Y'all My Daddy? who added a disapproving "I didn't like that song".
Remix #8 Edit
The theme was then remixed an eighth time by newcomer
Mike the Janitor in Episode 356: Heynong Man who added "Was that even a song?"
Remix #9 Edit
The theme was then remixed yet again by
Tiny in Episode 357: Modern Anti-Comedy who added an emphatic "That's a goooood song."
Remix #10 Edit
Much to the hatred of Scott, the song was remixed by
Willard "Willy" Mapelton in Episode 373: Vocal Fry , who added an irritating "That's not a very good song."
Remix #11 Edit
The theme got its eleventh remix in the first half of
Episode 386: Titbit for Tatbit, when Reverend Robert Parsimony added "The only good songs are hymns!"