Jukebox Jury is a segment of Comedy Bang! Bang! which hasn't been played in quite a while (presumed retired). The premise of Jukebox Jury is, Scott plays fan submitted songs which are then judged to be either Mustard or Pants depending on whether the guest likes the song or not and whether they prefer Mustard or Pants.

The guests are asked "Mustard or pants?" after the plugs theme in 388: Breath Before Death.

List of Episodes Featuring Jukebox JuryEdit

Episode Guests
154: Finger Guns

Marissa Wompler (Jessica St. Clair), Miss Listler (Lennon Parham)

141: Ladies Night

Tig NotaroRonna & Beverly (Jessica Chaffin & Jamie Denbo)

108: Pussy CPR

Rob CorddryErinn HayesDov Charney (James Adomian)

95: Phishing for Compliments

Natasha LeggeroHarris WittelsKing George VI (Matt Besser)

94: Dip Didda Dip Dow!

Ben SchwartzHot Dog (Andy Daly)

89: Great Big Hill of Hope Harris WittelsFabrice Fabrice and Bobby Bottleservice (Nick Kroll)
87: Droppin' Wallets! Nick ThuneChelsea Peretti
76.5: Don't Cry Rolling Skate Train

Zach GalifianakisLord Andrew Lloyd Webber (Paul F. Tompkins), Dillon Campbell

73: Featuring Betty White!

Nick SwardsonBill Cosby-Bukowski (Jon Daly)

70: Rock 'n Roll Dreams

Ted LeoAimee MannJon WursterMr. Brainwash (Paul F. Tompkins)

65: Welcome to Earwolf!

Randy & Jason SklarBob Ducca (Seth Morris)

55: Go Rent Delgo! Natasha Leggero, Jason Mantzoukas, Bob Ducca (Seth Morris)
16: Bob Odenkirk's Death Bed

Andy Dick, Bob Odenkirk, Chelsea Peretti

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.