The theme tune for Riddle Me This was originally Prince's "Partyman" from Batman. It was mentioned that it is actually a theme for the Joker and it would make more sense if it was a Riddler theme. After that, Scott began singing the Riddler theme a capella. The theme is now a clip from 284: A Thrilling CBB Adventure Hour of Croach the Tracker from Thrilling Adventure Hour (Mark Gagliardi) simply rapping "Riddler." In the clip, Scott comments that it is a good song.